730 registrants

Networking event for Poetry & Literature translators

Aug 7, 2013

Group discussion

How close does one have to stick to the original text? "The nearest police station, that's him."

You must log in before you can access most features of this event.

Schedule:

This session ended at 16:50

Description:

This discussion topic was suggested by ProZ.com member Edwin Miles:
How close does one have to stick to the original text? Is sentence level always appropriate, or is paragraph level enough? Can you leave out sentences entirely? How much leeway do/should you have? Is this decided in collaboration with the writer him/herself. etc.? The title above is a translation (by Ernst Kaiser/Eithne Wilkins) of "Er ist am nächsten daran," in Siegfried Lenz's "Deutschstunde" ("The German Lesson").

To help the flow of this chat and facilitate effective discussion please note the following format:
Questions will be posed as follows:
Q1. Where are located today?
Answers should use the following format:
A1. I am in Syracuse, NY USA

People who signed up for this focus group:

Alexandra Schneeuhr

સાઇપ્રસ

David Creuze

ફ્રાંસ

Bettina Myers

Last year I did a traineeship as a literary translator and translated two poems by the Ecuadorian poet Ramiro Oviedo. I managed to solve some translation problems about meaning and localization only in collaboration with him. How do you behave when you have to adjust a text from a culture to another?

Gabriele Monte

ઇટલી

Sandrine Guéant

ફ્રાંસ

Keen to see how others deal with these examples (and more).

Aïda Garcia Pons (X)

યૂનાઇટેડ સ્ટેટસ્

Rodica Stefan

Edwin Miles

જર્મની

johnkar

ગ્રીસ

I had lots of fights with my editor on this topic. ;)

Heléne van der Westhuizen

જર્મની

પોર્ટુગલ

નેધરલેન્ડ્સ

ઇરાન

યૂનાઇટેડ સ્ટેટસ્

Mariana S. Artieda Rico

આર્જેન્ટીના

How much leeway do you have in "improving a text," i.e. if you can express the idea in a more creative or interesting way than the author, is it alright to suggest it?

Arlene Lokomowitz

યૂનાઇટેડ સ્ટેટસ્

Brigitte Pellat (X)

ફ્રાંસ

Shobha Pawar

Huijiao Deng

ઇટલી

Really would like to share practice about he/she/it in translation practice Sp > Eng and Fr > Eng and general thoughts about literal versus more poetic translation.